American Idol Week 13

[innersanctum]

CJ must have fallen asleep on the American Idol thread. *L*

[CplCJ]

Nope-running a little late today.
Here goes:
Bucky-not bad, but not good.
Kellie-surprised she did bohemian Rhapsody, but unfortunately missed most of it-kids to bed...
Chris-I didn't know the song, but I thought his voice sounded good. Lacking a little of his stage presence.
Taylor. Fun. Very fun.
Katherine-missed completley, but going by the recap, not good. she will be leaving tonight.
Elliot-Sounded pretty good, but he has that hip hop thin going with slapping himself on the chest and dipping his legs. I don't care for that.
Paris. I thought the song was good, but when did she become "its Jackson if you're nasty"?
Ace continues to sing songs too slow. Did you hear Brian May say "No, I am NOT doing that to my own song...?" He may also be leaving tonight.

Is Paul Rogers singing wih Queen tonight?

[innersanctum]

Bottom 3...

Taylor
Katherine
Ace

Bye bye Ace!

[CplCJ]

I agree with your count with the exception of Taylor. I would swap out Paris. Thats Bennet if your nasty! Bye Bye Ace.

[innersanctum]

How could two people not even see Bucky going? Bad decision for America. However, I don't think he would have won it all anyway. At least he is locked into the American Idol Tour this summer.

Next week is Rod Stewart songs. I would have thought the producers would have put a little more thought into the performances.

What would be your ideal theme night for American Idol?

I would like to see them do the songs of Van Halen or maybe an alternative night (along the lines of Soft Cell or New Order) just to see what their versatility is.